Monday, April 16, 2012
The Catcher in the Rye: Post 2
I think that chapter 5 of The Catcher in the Rye shows a different and somewhat emotional side of Holden. He shows us that he has a side that has seen grief and has to deal with it. He seems somewhat afraid to right out tell us that he experiences sadness, but he gives us enough details that we can see that he really is normal in that regard. "Old Allie's baseball mitt. I happened to have it with me, in my suitcase, so I got it out and copied down the poems that were written on it." (39) He tells us that he has this very nostalgic side by saying that he just keeps this old baseball glove in his suitcase. He tries not to make that big a deal of it, but you can tell that it really does mean a lot to him. Holden then reminisces about how great Allie was, and how much we would've loved him. I can't really relate to Holden in the aspect of experiencing the grief he must've felt when his brother died, but I can understand the idea of trying to hold on to better memories. This is something that he almost seems to feel ashamed of, but he still wants to talk about it. I think he almost recognizes that this is something we all feel and all try to hold on to.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hey Alex i really like you point of vue and how you explain it with some quote it's really good! i like how you show how houlden is. I think you are right for everything cause i think houlden things that he's doing everything kind of wrong but he doesn't try to be better enought and i think he doesn't believe in himself cause he has been kick out from school tree times...
ReplyDeleteI agree about Holden's emotional side. I think that this is probably one of the only times that we've seen him this sincere about something. I also liked how you talked about how his "I don't care" attitude doesn't really work here because he really does care, and you can tell by the way he talks about his brother.
ReplyDeleteI think the exact same way. He is like a normal teenage boy where he kind of has to act tough and not show his sensitive side. Like a normal teenager he acts like he doesn't care about most things. Since the book is first person we can get inside his head and see how he really thinks. While he was talking about Allie you could tell he thinks about him and misses him.
ReplyDelete